Domination Chronicles: Pulp Legal Fiction - Tee-Hit-Ton v. United States

In this episode, Newcomb and d’Errico revisit Tee-Hit-Ton Indians v. United States, the 1955 Supreme Court decision that denied compensation for timber taken from Tlingit lands. The case is one of the clearest modern examples of Christian discovery functioning as U.S. property law.

The hosts call the opinion “pulp legal fiction” because its reasoning depends on inherited colonial stories rather than legitimate consent or justice. They compare the case with Brown v. Board of Education, showing how mid-century legal decisions could challenge one form of racial segregation while preserving another structure of domination against Native nations. The episode helps listeners see how discovery doctrine did not disappear after the Marshall Court. It was renewed and adapted in the twentieth century to protect land theft and federal authority. The conversation is a sharp reminder that legal fiction can have material consequences for peoples, forests, and nations.

Direct link